Home Office Mall - The Professional - IndustryPro
Shopping for a new computer? Here they are...the good, the bad and the truly awful. The world is full of great products and terrific deals. But before you buy , look below for the real scoop on what ultimately counts most... RELIABILITY .
The PC World report and ZDReview keep close tabs on who's
got the best of what. Here at Home Office Mall, we've been tracking their
reviews since mid-1995.
This synopsis is just that, a quick, historical look at overall results. It's DELL AGAIN! May 8, 2000 - Some vendors receive a wider range of scores. For example, some IBM customers confer high marks, while others score it poorly. That indicates inconsistencies by the vendor. Compaq took advantage of IBM's inconsistencies, besting Big Blue in both desktop and notebook categories. Compaq replaced IBM as the second highest rated vendor for notebooks and desktops. IBM fell to third place in notebooks and fifth place in desktops, behind Hewlett-Packard and Gateway. The company placed third in the Intel-based server category. Compaq's other notable scores: It was the only vendor to receive "exceptional" scores for technical support response and on-site support expertise. IBM's decline in desktops is due largely to delivery problems and uncompetitive pricing, the report says. It also notes that IBM offers a superior notebook product, but drops the ball on support. IBM placed fourth overall in the Intel server category. Gateway, HP, and Toshiba are the other major vendors appearing in the study. HP improved its scores in the server category, squeaking by Compaq to place second to Dell. It landed in third place in the desktops category, where the study calls the company an "average competitor" with improving scores in technical support response and on-site support. Gateway placed fourth in the desktop category. The report notes that many customers question the reliability of the company's desktops, citing new systems with defective parts. However, the survey says Gateway responds well to problems and "restores customer confidence" by quickly shipping replacement parts. Finally, top-selling notebook maker Toshiba rounds
out the notebook category with a fourth-place finish. The company continues
to score weakly in most areas, and customer loyalty rating is more than
21 percent lower than Dell's rating. . Source PCWorld
and TBRI September 23, 1999 - Only 20 percent of those polled say they own a Dell notebook, but 81 percent of those owners are very or extremely satisfied. Toshiba places second in ownership, with 23 percent of respondents owning its notebooks; 69 percent are very satisfied. IBM notebooks, carried by 21 percent of respondents,
are the third most widely owned but rank second in satisfaction, with
74 percent of IBM owners very satisfied with their purchase. Greenfield
surveyed 1000 business travelers for the study. The average age of respondents
was 38; 52 percent of them were male. Pollsters didn't ask what made respondents
happy or unhappy with their notebooks. Those questions may be addressed
in future studies, says Gail Janensch, a Greenfield spokesperson. Source:
PCWorld
A PLACE FOR YOUR STUFF: There's a storage product on the market that's being built into some new machines, and offered as an option on others. Developed by 3-M, it's called LS-120 technology, and it's available for both PC's and for notebooks. Unlike limited function Zip drives, LS-120 drives are compatable with every floppy diskette you already own, and each SuperDisk Diskette holds up to 120MB. That's the equivalent of 83 regular floppy diskettes. Plus, SuperDisk Diskettes are available at a lower cost per megabyte than many other high-capacity, removable solutions. You won't have to drag a heavy removable storage drive around with you anymore. Instead, travel light. Just tuck a SuperDisk in your pocket. Product design compatibility makes seriously good sense. GREAT IDEA. For PC's, see: IMATION --- for Mobile Computers, see: OR Technology HOW DID THE MANUFACTURERS STACK UP IN PRIOR
YEARS? In the January 1999 report, the top five were consistent, almost every way we looked at them. Best Reliability, Best Service, Best Prices, etc. Pretty good sign, wouldn't you say?. Link to detailed information is provided . The historical reports will be particularly helpful as you assess long-term product/company reliability vs. brand new contenders with well ranked products. You'll need the whole story if you plan on spending your hard-earned money on a new system. Take the time to do your homework now and you won't be sorry later. |
Reviews and Rankings from September '97 through November '99.
MONTHLY REVIEWS
Click for: NOVEMBER
1999 BEST BUDGET PC'S
Oct. 98 to Nov.'99, Dell ranked in top 3 for eight of those months. |
Click for LIST BY MANUFACTURER
CUMULATIVE
Manufacturers and Models of Top 5
PRODUCT | Price | CPU class | RAM installed | Installed hard drive (vendor spec) in GB |
Dell Dimension XPS R450 | $2529 | Pentium II-450 | 128 | 10 |
Dell OptiPlex GX1 400 | $2145 | Pentium II-400 | 64 | 6.4 |
Dell Dimension XPS R350 | $1899 | Pentium II-350 | 64 | 10 |
Dell Dimension XPS R400 | $2549 | Pentium II-400 | 96 | 14 |
Dell Dimension V333c | $1629 | Celeron-333 | 64 | 8.4 |
Sept 1998
ALSO: Sept. '98 Article - Cheap
PC's - How to buy them without getting ripped off.
Power Desktops 1. Dell Model: Dimension XPS D266 2. Dell Model: OptiPlex GXa266 3. Gateway 2000 Model: G6-266 4. Quantex Model: QP6/300 SM-3x 5. Micron Model: Millennia XKU 300 |
Budget Desktops 1. Dell Dimension XPS D266 2. Gateway 2000 G6-233 3. Gateway 2000 GP5-233 4. Gateway 2000 E-3110 233 5. Micro Express MicroFlex-P225J |
Power Home Systems 1. Gateway 2000 G6-233 2. Dell Dimension XPS D300 3. Micron Millennia Mme with Fusion 3D 4. Gateway 2000 G6-300XL 5. Quantex QP6/300 M-4x |
Budget Home Systems 1. Dell Dimension XPS D233c 2. Gateway 2000 G5-200 3. Quantex QP5/233 M-2 4. HP Pavilion 3100 5. Packard Bell Multimedia M415 |
The PC World June 1997 report was based on the responses of 13,510 respondents to PC World's Reliability and Service survey between Aug. 1, 1996 and June 25, 1997 . It was a little bit of an eyebrow raiser, indicating what we viewed as a shake-out.
Dell was currently all alone at the top of the hill in "Best" category, with Micron dropping back to a "Good" rating. Both IBM and Gateway 2000 rocketed upwards from previous "Fair" ratings to achieve "Good" this time around, and both Apple and Hewlett Packard continue to maintain their long-standing "Good" positions.
And if you can say anything good about Packard Bell, it's that they're consistent, their customers having once again cheerfully voted this company their all-time worst rating.
The following Company listings are alphabetical within ratings categories.
BEST | GOOD Overall | - FAIR- | POOR | - WORST |
- Dell- | Apple Gateway 2000 Hewlett Packard IBM Micron |
Compaq Digital Quantex |
AST | Acer NEC Packard Bell |
November 1996 UPDATE Based on approx. 11,776 questionaires received between Dec. 19, 1995 and July 26, 1996. |
March 1996 UPDATE based on approximately 17,800 questionnaires returned to PC World between May 20 and Nov. 20, 1995 by individuals who bought a PC within the last two years (since Nov. 1993). | December 1995 UPDATE based on approximately 19,800 questionnaires returned to PC World in the first half of 1995. | Primary report June 1995 . Report compiled from 150,000 responses to Reliability & Service Monitor fax survey. |
Detailed information on the November '96 report and the accompanying articles may be found at PC World.
Company listings in categories which appear below are ALPHABETICALLY arranged.
REPORT DATE |
BEST | GOOD | FAIR | POOR | WORST |
Nov. 1996 UPDATE |
BEST OVERALL Dell Micron BEST RELIABILITY Apple Compaq Dell H-P Micron BEST SERVICE Dell Micron |
GOOD OVERALL Apple AT&T (NCR) Compaq Digital H-P GOOD RELIABILITY AT&T (NCR) Digital GOOD SERVICE Digital H-P |
FAIR OVERALL Gateway 2000 IBM Quantex FAIR RELIABILITY Gateway 2000 IBM NEC FAIR SERVICE Acer Apple AT&T (NCR) Compaq Gateway 2000 IBM MidWestMicro Quantex |
POOR OVERALL Acer MWMicro NEC POOR REL. Acer Quantex POOR SVC AST NEC |
WORST OVERALL AST PackardBell WORST REL. AST MWMicro PackardBell WORST SVC PackardBell |
March 1996 UPDATE |
BEST OVERALL Apple Compaq Digital Hewlett-Packard BEST RELIABILITY Apple Compaq Digital Micron Hewlett-Packard BEST SERVICE Apple Apple Compaq Dell Digital Hewlett-Packard IBM |
GOOD OVERALL Dell IBM Micron NEC GOOD RELIABLITY AST Dell IBM NEC GOOD SERVICE Compudyne Micron NEC |
FAIR OVERALL Acer AST Compudyne Gateway2000 LeadingEdge FAIR RELIABILITY Acer Gateway2000 LeadingEdge PackardBell FAIR SERVICE AST Gateway MidwestMicro Quantex |
POOR OVERALL MidwestMicro PackardBell Pionex Quantex POOR RELIABILITY Compudyne Pionex Quantex Zeos POOR SERVICE Acer LeadingEdge Pionex |
N/A You wouldn't want it anyway |
Dec. 1995 UPDATE |
BEST OVERALL Apple Compaq Hewlett-Packard Micron BEST RELIABILITY Apple Compaq Digital Hewlett-Packard Micron BEST SERVICE Apple Compaq IBM |
GOOD OVERALL Dell IBM Micron NEC GOOD RELIABILITY AST Dell IBM NEC GOOD SERVICE Compudyne Micron |
FAIR OVERALL Acer AST Compudyne Gateway2000 LeadingEdge FAIR REL Acer Gateway2000 LeadingEdge PackardBell FAIR SERVICE AST Gateway MidWestMicro Quantex |
POOR OVERALL MidWestMicro PackardBell Pionex Quantex POOR REL. Compudyne Pionex Quantex Zeos POOR SERVICE Acer LeadingEdge Pionex |
|
June 1995 Primary Report | BEST OVERALL Apple Compaq Dell Digital Hewlett Packard BEST RELIABILITY Apple AT&T (NCR) Compaq Dell Digital Hewlett-Packard BEST SERVICE Apple Compaq Dell Digital Hewlett-Packard Micron NEC |
GOOD OVERALL AST AT&T(NCR) IBM Micron NEC GOOD RELIABILITY AST IBM NEC GOOD SERVICE AST IBM Quantex |
FAIR OVERALL Acer DTK Gateway2000 Pionex Quantex Tandy VTech FAIR REL. Acer DTK Gateway2000 Micron PackardBell Pionex Tandy VTech FAIR SERVICE AT&T (NCR) Compudyne Gateway Insight Pionex |
POOR OVERALL Compudyne Insight Leading Edge Packard Bell Zeos POOR REL. Leading Edge Quantex Zeos POOR SERVICE Acer DTK LeadingEdge Tandy VTech Zeos |
We're in the midst of updating this section, adding even more resources for you.
The Best and Worst Places to Buy a PC
Ziff-Davis Product Reviews
Reviews cover: PC's, Peripherals, Software, Internet, & Network Products
Remote Back-up service: Think you don't need it? Think again. Think about fires, tornadoes, brownouts, earthquakes, hurricanes, floods...and oh yes, did you know that more than 300,000 insurance claims for lightning strikes are filed annually?. Guess which electronic device in your home is the most attractive to the average lightning bolt out for a good time? ---Okay, forget natural disasters. Think about things like hard disk failures, software conflicts, viruses, and plain old computing xaeitnalerawhern....zzzip BLANK. Agggghhhh, it's GONE.
The OFFSITE backup company we recommend?
Atrieva , user friendly and reliable,
with a flat fee for unlimited storage.
Removable Storage Devices Note: Assess your needs. Check out the seriously practical new LS-120 Drives
Other equipment such as printers, scanners, notebooks, motherboards, etc. which you'll also want to research before purchasing.
|